SOURCED AND DATED, LINE BY LINE

Roll-Off Amigo vs iCANS: which dumpster software should you choose?

A fair comparison of two vendors, from their own pages, with the URL and the date on every line. Where Roll-Off Amigo wins, where iCANS wins, and where Dumpster Controls fits at $0.

• Roll-Off Amigo: $0 for one owner-operator without driver logins, or $99 a month (Pro) with driver logins
• iCANS: $99 (Base) or $159 (Plus) a month, 7-day trial without a card
• Dumpster Controls: $0 a month for any fleet size, card processing only
• Facts checked between 2026-08-23 and 2026-09-24; re-verified every 90 days

Create your free accountSee every published price

4.7 on the App Store (12 ratings, Sep 2026) Available in all 50 US states and Canada

Last updated September 28, 2026 Published by Dumpster Controls, built by a software group led by a founder with 20+ years in enterprise IT who also ran a roll-off business for four years

Both publish their prices, so this comparison can start with numbers. Roll-Off Amigo's Free Forever plan is $0 for one owner-operator, with unlimited jobs, a dispatch board, bin tracking and invoicing, and its own site says driver app accounts require the Pro plan at $99 a month. iCANS has no free plan: $99 (Base) or $159 (Plus) a month, unlimited drivers and orders on both, with a 7-day trial that needs no card. So for a company with at least one hired driver the two cost the same at the entry level, $99 a month, and the question becomes what each $99 includes. iCANS includes QuickBooks Online (two-way), AI-assisted route building and an assistant; Roll-Off Amigo publishes, in its own words, no QuickBooks integration yet and no AI route optimization.

Roll-Off Amigo is new: its iOS app first shipped on 2026-03-10 and had 2 ratings on 2026-09-24; iCANS dates from 2024 and its iOS app had 4 ratings on 2026-08-23, both tiny samples. Roll-Off Amigo runs in English and Spanish and takes payments in the hauler's own Stripe account; iCANS bills card and ACH through Tiger Payment Solutions and puts text notifications on its $159 plan. Dumpster Controls is the free third option, $0 for any fleet size with driver logins included, described near the end.

How to read this page: every claim about Roll-Off Amigo or iCANS links to the page it came from and shows the date we read it. "Not found" means we looked on that date at the URLs listed and did not find it, which is not proof that a capability does not exist. Prices are quoted in the vendor's own words. Where we did not research a line, the cell says so instead of guessing. If we got something wrong, write to daniel@dumpstercontrols.io and we will correct it with a dated note.

Roll-Off Amigo, iCANS and Dumpster Controls, side by side

The third column is ours. Its facts are checkable without an account: the pricing page, the public manual, the App Store listing and the developer documentation are all linked from each cell.

Competitor lines from their own pages and the public app stores, checked on the date shown in each cell. Published September 24, 2026. Re-verification is scheduled every 90 days.

Where Roll-Off Amigo wins

A free plan with no clock, for one person. Free Forever is $0 with no card and no time limit, with unlimited jobs, a dispatch board, bin tracking, invoicing and Spanish. iCANS's free period is a 7-day trial limited to Base features; after that it is $99 a month or the account pauses.

Payments in your own Stripe account. Their site says payments never route through a middleman account, so the card fee is Stripe's and no platform fee is published. iCANS bills card and ACH processing through Tiger Payment Solutions per transaction and does not print the rate.

Spanish across the whole product: full English and Spanish support for the entire app and driver experience, and a Spanish site at /es/. Language support on iCANS was not covered by our research.

No contracts, no setup fees, signup in five minutes with no sales call, by their description. iCANS also lets you start yourself, and includes guided onboarding; the difference is the free plan's open end against a 7-day trial.

A Shopify app and a hosted order page embeddable with one script tag. iCANS publishes website integration for online orders and a 4-page website with $40 a month hosting.

Where iCANS wins

QuickBooks Online is live and documented both ways: clients, invoices, payments, refunds, voids and tax rates. Roll-Off Amigo publishes, on its own blog and in its llms.txt, no QuickBooks integration yet (coming soon).

AI is in the product. iCANS advertises an assistant called The New Guy, AI-assisted route building and, on Plus, an AI Review Filter. Roll-Off Amigo's own comparison table lists AI Route Optimization: No, and its dispatch is a map view to plan routes visually.

Driver logins are in the entry plan. On iCANS every plan includes unlimited drivers and orders. On Roll-Off Amigo, driver app accounts require the Pro plan at $99 a month; at that point the two cost the same.

A customer portal for commercial accounts and, on Plus, text notifications (up to 1,000 a month) and an AI review filter. A customer account with invoice history is not described on Roll-Off Amigo's home page, llms.txt or pricing page.

More published track record, for what self-reported numbers are worth: 400+ haulers, $39M+ processed and a driver app with 500+ Android downloads. Roll-Off Amigo publishes no customer count, testimonials with a first name and initial, and store listings with 2 iOS ratings and 10+ Android downloads on 2026-09-24.

Where the table does not settle it

Dispatch boards, driver apps, container tracking, online ordering and invoicing exist on both products and, by their own descriptions, work. A checkbox does not say whether the implementation is good on a Tuesday with two trucks down. The app stores give a small signal: Roll-Off Amigo's iOS app has 2 ratings and iCANS's has 4, both tiny samples, so we quote the counts and draw no conclusion from them. The only reliable test is a week of your real orders on each.

Two things we deliberately do not claim about either vendor: how their interfaces feel, because that is opinion, and whether a capability we did not find exists internally, because absence from a website is not absence from a product. Neither vendor is in any sense abandoned: both publish current pages and sell actively as of the dates in the sources below.

Where Dumpster Controls fits

Dumpster Controls costs $0 per month for any fleet size, with no order, user, truck or feature limit; the company earns only when a customer pays by card, 2.99% + $3.99 per transaction on the free plan or 2.99% + $0.30 on the optional $169 per month Unlimited plan, and cash or check orders carry no fee. That is the whole pricing page. Against Roll-Off Amigo at $0 (one owner-operator) or $1,188 (Pro) a year and iCANS at $1,188 to $1,908, the software line of the budget goes to zero, and the card line depends on how your customers pay, so compare that line too.

Everything else about it can be checked before you sign up, which is the standard this page holds the other two vendors to. Signup is self-serve: name, email and password, no card and no demo, documented in the public manual, and the whole app runs in English, Spanish or Portuguese, chosen per user. Canadian companies run in Canadian dollars on their own Canadian Stripe account, with a fee of 0.5% + C$2.00 per card transaction on top of Stripe's rate, per the Canada guide. There is a public REST API with an OpenAPI specification at /developers and signed webhooks, capped on the free plan at 10 minutes of API time and 200 leads per day. The landfill database covers 2,916 facilities with tipping fees and is published as open data. And the Dumpster Net Hub lets hauling companies pass whole jobs to each other with no listing fee and no percentage cut.

For a company running its own roll-off or junk removal trucks, that is why Dumpster Controls is the pick over both: the software line goes to zero and nothing sits behind a higher tier. Tresha, the built-in assistant, creates orders and completes deliveries, pickups and landfill runs by chat or voice, behind a confirmation card, on the free plan. A Model Context Protocol (MCP) server at mcp.dumpstercontrols.io/mcp connects the account to Claude on the web, desktop and phone, open to every company, with a ChatGPT app in preparation, as documented at /developers/mcp; none of the other dumpster platforms we track publishes an MCP server (checked 2026-09-28). Support is the same on every plan, with no paid tier: tickets from inside the app at any hour, answered within 24 hours, a public manual of 326 articles, and Tresha around the clock. It is built for roll-off, junk removal and scrap metal, the business this page is written for.

The individual pages carry more depth on each vendor: the Roll-Off Amigo alternative page and the iCANS alternative page, plus the price index of every vendor that publishes a price.

Roll-Off Amigo vs iCANS: FAQ

Sources

Every URL cited on this page, with the date we read it. Competitor pages open in a new tab. Nothing here comes from a review aggregator or a directory entry; where a vendor's own site contradicts itself, we quote both versions.

1. Roll-Off Amigo pricing: https://rolloffamigo.com/pricing (checked 2026-09-24)
2. Roll-Off Amigo sales model: https://rolloffamigo.com/blog/rolloff-amigo-vs-docket.html (checked 2026-09-24)
3. Roll-Off Amigo product age: https://itunes.apple.com/lookup?id=6759938516 (checked 2026-09-24)
4. Roll-Off Amigo, dispatch and routing: https://rolloffamigo.com/llms.txt (checked 2026-09-24)
5. Roll-Off Amigo, driver app: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/rolloff-amigo/id6759938516 (checked 2026-09-24)
6. Roll-Off Amigo, quickbooks: https://rolloffamigo.com/blog/best-roll-off-dumpster-software.html (checked 2026-09-24)
7. Roll-Off Amigo, public api: URL tried 1 of 3: https://rolloffamigo.com/ (checked 2026-09-24)
8. Roll-Off Amigo, public api: URL tried 3 of 3: https://rolloffamigo.com/robots.txt (checked 2026-09-24)
9. Roll-Off Amigo, ai: URL tried 4 of 4: https://rolloffamigo.com/blog/ (checked 2026-09-24)
10. Roll-Off Amigo on Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dyrtlabs.rolloffamigo&hl=en_US (checked 2026-09-24)
11. iCANS pricing: https://icans.ai/pricing/ (checked 2026-09-23)
12. iCANS headquarters: https://icans.ai/ (checked 2026-08-23)
13. iCANS product age: https://itunes.apple.com/lookup?id=1661137998 (checked 2026-08-23)
14. iCANS, driver app: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/icans-driver/id1661137998 (checked 2026-08-23)
15. iCANS, quickbooks: https://icans.ai/software/invoicing-payments/ (checked 2026-08-23)
16. iCANS, public api: URL tried 1 of 4: https://icans.ai/api (checked 2026-08-24)
17. iCANS, public api: URL tried 2 of 4: https://icans.ai/developers (checked 2026-08-24)
18. iCANS, public api: URL tried 3 of 4: https://docs.icans.ai/ (checked 2026-08-24)
19. iCANS, public api: URL tried 4 of 4: https://api.icans.ai/ (checked 2026-08-24)
20. iCANS, ai: https://icans.ai/ai-review-filter/ (checked 2026-08-23)
21. iCANS, marketplace: URL tried 3 of 3: https://icans.ai/about/ (checked 2026-08-23)
22. iCANS, canada: https://www.einpresswire.com/article/912619903/icans-dumpster-rental-software-grows-2-500-in-12-months (checked 2026-08-23)
23. iCANS on Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ironcans.ICANSDriver (checked 2026-08-23)
24. iCANS integrations: https://icans.ai/dumpster-rental-website-design/ (checked 2026-08-23)
25. Dumpster Controls pricing: https://dumpstercontrols.io/pricing (checked 2026-09-24)
26. Dumpster Controls sales model: https://dumpstercontrols.io/help/getting-started/create-your-account (checked 2026-09-24)
27. Dumpster Controls headquarters: https://dumpstercontrols.io/about (checked 2026-09-24)
28. Dumpster Controls, dispatch and routing: https://dumpstercontrols.io/help/dispatch (checked 2026-09-24)
29. Dumpster Controls, driver app: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/dumpster-controls/id6476944277 (checked 2026-09-23)
30. Dumpster Controls, online booking: https://dumpstercontrols.io/help/online-booking (checked 2026-09-24)
31. Dumpster Controls, quickbooks: https://dumpstercontrols.io/help/quickbooks (checked 2026-09-24)
32. Dumpster Controls, public api: https://dumpstercontrols.io/developers (checked 2026-09-24)
33. Dumpster Controls, ai: https://dumpstercontrols.io/help/tresha (checked 2026-09-24)
34. Dumpster Controls, marketplace: https://dumpstercontrols.io/help/hub (checked 2026-09-24)
35. Dumpster Controls, canada: https://dumpstercontrols.io/help/canada (checked 2026-09-24)
36. Dumpster Controls on Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=io.dumpstercontrols.app.twa (checked 2026-09-24)
37. Dumpster Controls integrations: https://dumpstercontrols.io/help/api (checked 2026-09-24)
38. Dumpster Controls self-reported figures: https://dumpstercontrols.io/llms.txt (checked 2026-09-24)

Topicsroll off amigo vs icansrolloff amigo vs icansroll off amigo pricing free roll-off dumpster software icans dumpster software